View Full Version : is this a good PSU?
polishnightmare
03-04-2008, 02:47 AM
BFG Tech 800W
http://hardwarelogic.com/news/136/AR...008-01-03.html
i found it at best buy for 130 bucks theres like 3 left so im wondering if i should
buy it or is there ne better ones out there same watts or even less but better?
for around the same price
just wanted to know cuz found out i need around 620W+ to run my comp under 90% load
oldmanclint
03-07-2008, 03:14 PM
that link doesn't lead to a specific product.
what makes you think you need 620W+?
Paulieg
03-07-2008, 03:29 PM
I'm not sure who is making the BFG power supplies right now, but I've heard several complaints recently. I think you can do better for $120.
bruins004
03-07-2008, 03:34 PM
BFG PSUs are a lil iffy.
Plus for that kind of money you can get a much better brand.
Take a look at Corsair, Seasonic, Forton Source (FSP) PSUs.
AsRock
03-07-2008, 05:18 PM
It would help if people knew what system you have. If you need around 750W go for some thing of PC & Power.
http://www.pcpowercooling.com/
Here' the review on mine
http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTM2OSw5LCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA==
And they just done a review on the New Turbo Cool 860 ( pricy but you surly get a great PSU. ).
http://enthusiast.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTQ2MywxLCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA==
Tatty_One
03-07-2008, 05:33 PM
the BFG PSU's are tier 4 products according to Tom's Hardware PSU rating tables, the definition of which is......OK, As Paulieg says....shop around, you can do better for $120, have a look for the OCZ StealthXStream 600W, thats a Tier 3 for Tier 4 prices and in fact cheaper, I had one and for a mid ranged PSU at almost a budget price it is well worth the money, in the UK (expensive) it is around $90.
asb2106
03-07-2008, 05:38 PM
It would help if people knew what system you have. If you need around 750W go for some thing of PC & Power.
http://www.pcpowercooling.com/
I have to agree here, I think the 150 bucks that the PC Power & cooling 750 costs, is the best money spent on a Power supply. These by far are the most stable and consistant PS I have worked with. AND they can power anything you throw at them!
Creatre
03-07-2008, 05:52 PM
the BFG PSU's are tier 4 products according to Tom's Hardware PSU rating tables, the definition of which is......OK, As Paulieg says....shop around, you can do better for $120, have a look for the OCZ StealthXStream 600W, thats a Tier 3 for Tier 4 prices and in fact cheaper, I had one and for a mid ranged PSU at almost a budget price it is well worth the money, in the UK (expensive) it is around $90.
Just bought this PSU myself. I've heard a lot of really good things about the OCZ PSU's, especially the "Bang for the buck" of this one. :toast:
asb2106
03-07-2008, 05:54 PM
Just bought this PSU myself. I've heard a lot of really good things about the OCZ PSU's, especially the "Bang for the buck" of this one. :toast:
OCZ makes great PSU's, OCZ actually owns PC Power & Cooling now too! PC P&C still makes there own but they are owned by OCZ
calvary1980
03-07-2008, 05:59 PM
OCZ Powersupplies are bang for buck because they die at random :)
- Christine
I agree with asb2106 & Christine, PC P&C 750W is a Tier 1 PSU and probably the best money can buy, i had one for 10 months and had no problems. As for OCZ, especially the gamexstream, are not as reliable, i researched both when doing this build. Actually, if memory serves me right jonnyguru put OCZ in Tier 3.
SirKeldon
03-07-2008, 06:56 PM
Well, since i didn't find the PC Power & Cooling and as asb2106 said, PC Power & Cooling is now owned by OCZ, i'm sure they improved their way of making the PSU's so i gave a chance to them, i purchased last tuesday a ModXStream of 780W, don't know if it's gonna to be reliable at all with time as you said, but i'm getting stuck with the results in this 90nm 125W OC'd almost to 160W. We'll see :)
Tatty_One
03-07-2008, 08:44 PM
I agree with asb2106 & Christine, PC P&C 750W is a Tier 1 PSU and probably the best money can buy, i had one for 10 months and had no problems. As for OCZ, especially the gamexstream, are not as reliable, i researched both when doing this build. Actually, if memory serves me right jonnyguru put OCZ in Tier 3.
Actually if you look at the tables, a GameXStream is Tier 2 and thats VERY good but I agree, PC P&W are top dollar but for his price range, the OCZ's are good bang for buck, I had the StealthXStream and whilst only a mid range unit, I had nothing but stability and praise for it.
WarEagleAU
03-07-2008, 09:03 PM
Take a look at Corsairs TX series. Those are very nice for that kind of cash.
calvary1980
03-07-2008, 09:04 PM
Stealth, Game XStream series just die and I have no explanation to why you can see people complaining about problematic cases or the power supplies just roll over in google. of course someone will say they own one and have had no problems but that could be to a multitude of reasons maybe they don't put it to the test? either way you don't have to know about capacitors or heatsinks to spot a Quality Power Supply like the Corsair or PCP&C. BFG is descent but at that wattage range you can find better.
- Christine
Tatty_One
03-07-2008, 09:05 PM
Stealth, Game XStream series just die and I have no explanation to why you can see people complaining about problematic cases or the power supplies just roll over in google. of course someone will say they own one and have had no problems but that could be to a multitude of reasons maybe they don't put it to the test? either way you don't have to know about capacitors or heatsinks to spot a Quality Power Supply like the Corsair or PCP&C.
- Christine
Lol, the only reliable way to judge a piece of harware is from your own experiences, you wont find any hardware out there that has not had failures, I will let you decide if I put mine to the test when I had it, it ran a Quad at 4gig, a voltmodded 8800GT at 840mhz on the core (it fried)....the GT that was not the OCZ :D......3 hard drives, 2 optical drives, 4gb of heavily overclocked ram, an x38 motherboard etc etc, now whilst that might not quite be pulling 600W at peak load on the system that will be giving it some fairly serious stress.
calvary1980
03-07-2008, 09:09 PM
congratulations you had a power supply that did what it was supposed to it's still crap.
- Christine
Tatty_One
03-07-2008, 09:16 PM
congratulations you had a power supply that did what it was supposed to it's still crap.
- Christine
So I suppose that working on your theory your PSU is crap? because people have had to RMA them in the past because of failures................
http://forum.thermaltake.com/viewtopic.php?p=9053&sid=d2d68a0c418eb3a72dc13f960b8315b6
calvary1980
03-07-2008, 09:19 PM
Thermaltake was the only choice at this wattage range at the time, I hear what your saying but OCZ Power Supplies die more often than not. Fugger uses the exact same model, eat a tim tam :)
- Christine
Tatty_One
03-07-2008, 09:35 PM
Thermaltake was the only choice at this wattage range at the time, I hear what your saying but OCZ Power Supplies die more often than not. next time eat a tim tam before posting besides Fugger uses the exact same model :P
- Christine
I am not suggesting that an OCZ is better than a Thermaltake, after all I have a Thermaltake too! However, the way you have worded your posts so far suggest that based on info on the internet etc about failures with OCZ units they are crap, but that does not apply to failures with thermaltake units?
Edit: Die more often than not? so over half of all OCZ's fail........evidence?.....links?......
Actually if you look at the tables, a GameXStream is Tier 2 and thats VERY good but I agree, PC P&W are top dollar but for his price range, the OCZ's are good bang for buck, I had the StealthXStream and whilst only a mid range unit, I had nothing but stability and praise for it.
Actually, we are both wrong, jonnyguru put the Silencer 750w (and Corsairs) in Tier 3 and OCZ in Tier 4. I confused the Silencer with Turbo-Cool 1000w, thats the Tier 1 PSU.
http://www.jonnyguru.com/forums/showthread.php?t=103
SirKeldon
03-07-2008, 10:30 PM
I really want to think OCZ improved their way of production stealing the knowledge to PC P&C to avoid that hardware fails you're saying, all the companies take a further look to these kind of forums to improve the quality and the performance, sincerely i'm wishing it cause OCZ seems a serious brand and its reputation on memory is perfect ... last tuesday thinking on that i acquired a modular one, not StealthXStream or GameXStream, it's a ModXStream and it's 12V quad-rail powered with 20A each one, was more powerful than the PC P&C Silencer Quad 750W (just one rail of 60A for 12V in front of the 80A -20x4- and 24A to 3.33V in front of 30A this one is giving) and of course it was modular, which means a better cable management for me ... and if the tech inside is good as PC P&C as it should be since they're the same brand and ... or PC P&C performance decreases or OCZ one increases, there's no other chance since they're merged.
I really hope mine is one of the other 50% that won't fail ... but if it was, in how much time should i expect for the popping?
Tatty_One
03-08-2008, 11:52 AM
Actually, we are both wrong, jonnyguru put the Silencer 750w (and Corsairs) in Tier 3 and OCZ in Tier 4. I confused the Silencer with Turbo-Cool 1000w, thats the Tier 1 PSU.
http://www.jonnyguru.com/forums/showthread.php?t=103
Ummmm OK but I beleive I specifically said Tom's Hardware rating, so I beleive I was not actually wrong, as you can see here: :)
http://www.tomswiki.com/page/Tiered+PSU+Listings?t=anon
Tom's also rates specific to model and rating, hence the GameXStream is in Tier 2 whilst some other models are in lower tiers.
Tatty_One
03-08-2008, 12:05 PM
I really want to think OCZ improved their way of production stealing the knowledge to PC P&C to avoid that hardware fails you're saying, all the companies take a further look to these kind of forums to improve the quality and the performance, sincerely i'm wishing it cause OCZ seems a serious brand and its reputation on memory is perfect ... last tuesday thinking on that i acquired a modular one, not StealthXStream or GameXStream, it's a ModXStream and it's 12V quad-rail powered with 20A each one, was more powerful than the PC P&C Silencer Quad 750W (just one rail of 60A for 12V in front of the 80A -20x4- and 24A to 3.33V in front of 30A this one is giving) and of course it was modular, which means a better cable management for me ... and if the tech inside is good as PC P&C as it should be since they're the same brand and ... or PC P&C performance decreases or OCZ one increases, there's no other chance since they're merged.
I really hope mine is one of the other 50% that won't fail ... but if it was, in how much time should i expect for the popping?
Well as I said earlier, I can only speak from personal expereince, there are a lot of OCZ users in these forums and from what I can tell, they cant speak highly enough of them, and TBH, with the GameXStream and Evo Stream in Tier 2, that would suggest those particular models are good, like I said, all hardware fails, if you can find any PSU that has not I would very much like to try one of them out! personally, I dont think there are any abnormal issues with OCZ.
AsRock
03-08-2008, 03:03 PM
i think they brought PC & Power to make there OCZ PSU's stronger. Al so think they did it to get 2 parts of the PSU argument for example modular and dual rails as PC & Power swear in saying that one rail and not modular are better there fore getting my interest with PC & Power products and others with OCZ.
Judas
03-08-2008, 03:22 PM
Had OCZ700GXSSLI damn nice psu cant find a bad thing to say about it. But my new one is damn nice too :)
Ummmm OK but I beleive I specifically said Tom's Hardware rating, so I beleive I was not actually wrong, as you can see here: :)
http://www.tomswiki.com/page/Tiered+PSU+Listings?t=anon
Tom's also rates specific to model and rating, hence the GameXStream is in Tier 2 whilst some other models are in lower tiers.
We are talking about different ratings, LOL, i just trust jonnyguru a lot more than i trust toms.
AsRock
03-08-2008, 05:06 PM
We are talking about different ratings, LOL, i just trust jonnyguru a lot more than i trust toms.
Same here but i trust http://www.hardocp.com more than either of them.
Tatty_One
03-08-2008, 05:26 PM
We are talking about different ratings, LOL, i just trust jonnyguru a lot more than i trust toms.
Thats as may be but my point there was that in Tom's it has it as a Tier 2 which was what I said.......and many would Trust Tom's over Jonnyguru also :p but as I said early, I trust myself more than both, and my experience of OCZ PSU's is fantastic.
I trust myself more than both.
LOL, aint that the truth! ;)
The reason i like jonnyguru's reviews is cause the guy really knows his shit and speaks the truth about his findings, toms on the other hand have been negligent/biased at times, but they are not bad overall, they are just much bigger than most other publishers and therefore more well known
best PSU's available at any wattage...but I recommened 750W or up to 1000w for future proofing:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&N=2010320058+50009830&name=PC+Power+%26+Cooling
vBulletin® v3.7.0, Copyright ©2000-2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.