PDA

View Full Version : Whats Best? (CPU Cooler)


kyle2020
05-17-2008, 07:22 PM
Which is best, from your experience:

Arctic Cooling Freezer Pro

Or

Zalman 9700?

Cheers!

niko084
05-17-2008, 07:25 PM
AC Pro by FAR.

But there are better ones.

panchoman
05-17-2008, 07:26 PM
why not get something better like a xigmatek rifle 120mm or a thermalright ultra 120?

niko084
05-17-2008, 07:32 PM
Xigmatek is what I was going to say, forgot the name.

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 07:37 PM
im not getting the xigmatek because it stands too tall for my case side.

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 07:39 PM
**so does the thermalright if i remember correctly**

marsey99
05-17-2008, 07:40 PM
ifx-14 :D

of those 2 its close tbh

f7p gets my vote tho for its price/performance, the zalman looks miles better tho....

niko084
05-17-2008, 07:40 PM
They make more than one, and most of them are superior to the AC Pro.
But the AC Pro is perfectly fine if you know that will fit for sure :)

marsey99
05-17-2008, 07:42 PM
loads out perform the acpro now, ocz vendeta 2 is one you should look at if size is an issue.

CrackerJack
05-17-2008, 07:43 PM
I would get xigmatek it's the best bang for the buck. How much does it run in the UK. In the states it runs around $40 with shipping:)

department76
05-17-2008, 07:46 PM
i have a 9700 and it does wonders, that's not to say there isn't something better out there though.

niko084
05-17-2008, 07:49 PM
i have a 9700 and it does wonders, that's not to say there isn't something better out there though.

Ya they are very good by all means, my bro has one on a P4 3.0 and it never crosses 70c, in a case with absolutely no air flow.

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 07:50 PM
I would get xigmatek it's the best bang for the buck. How much does it run in the UK. In the states it runs around $40 with shipping:)

the xigmatek goes for like £18, so practically $40 haha.

CDdude55
05-17-2008, 08:03 PM
AC Pro is a good cooler. I have one and it cools very well. But i can't tell you much about the Zalman 9700 but Zalman does also have some of the best coolers around. AC does have some darn good thermal paste to.:)

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 08:04 PM
AC Pro is a good cooler. I have one and it cools very well. But i can't tell you much about the Zalman 9700 but Zalman does also have some of the best coolers around. AC does have some darn good thermal paste to.:)

agreed - plus the 9700 is like £40, the freezer pro like £15 - ima order the freezer pro i reckon. i was running orthos last night and had load temps of 70 degrees, i wasnt best impressed.

niko084
05-17-2008, 08:07 PM
agreed - plus the 9700 is like £40, the freezer pro like £15 - ima order the freezer pro i reckon. i was running orthos last night and had load temps of 70 degrees, i wasnt best impressed.

Give you an idea on the AC Pro,my processor @ 1.5 volts does not cross 51c even after 20+ hours on orthos.

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 08:08 PM
Give you an idea on the AC Pro,my processor @ 1.5 volts does not cross 51c even after 20+ hours on orthos.

fantastic - and at that price i am impressed. The decision is final! ordering one monday! :toast:

Might i ask what idle temps are?

CrackerJack
05-17-2008, 08:11 PM
I got around 47c full load at 1.325 no overclock. That's the reason why i got another cooler. But every chips is different, you might actually be able running it cooler than niko's chip with the AC

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 08:17 PM
I got around 47c full load at 1.325 no overclock. That's the reason why i got another cooler. But every chips is different, you might actually be able running it cooler than niko's chip with the AC

hopefully . . . then i need to find out how to raise my voltages seeing as my mobo only allows 1.35V and i can only go to 1.39 using a program :banghead: :banghead: :banghead:

MainframeTM
05-17-2008, 08:18 PM
I ordered a AC Pro on friday..it's here in town already sitting @ the UPS place..getting it on monday!

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 08:19 PM
*hate to double post, but*

currently im at 46 degrees on idle =O and people get 50 degrees on load with a freezer?!?


should be an investment in itself :D

niko084
05-17-2008, 08:20 PM
*hate to double post, but*

currently im at 46 degrees on idle =O and people get 50 degrees on load with a freezer?!?


should be an investment in itself :D

Well I also have a Core2 but they are pretty good either way... The thermal paste that comes on them I believe is MX or w/e its pretty good too.

I idle pretty much room temperature.

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 08:22 PM
Well I also have a Core2 but they are pretty good either way... The thermal paste that comes on them I believe is MX or w/e its pretty good too.

I idle pretty much room temperature.

yeah, i read the paste was spot on and didnt need replacing . . . room temp at idle? brilliant. getting rather excited now haha :D

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 08:24 PM
I ordered a AC Pro on friday..it's here in town already sitting @ the UPS place..getting it on monday!

take it you missed delivery? done that a few times myself, is an annoyance!

do me a favour, post us some thermal results / pictures once it arrives? that would be good, just before i purchase mine.

* 5 stars now :D *

250th post :D

Kursah
05-17-2008, 08:28 PM
im not getting the xigmatek because it stands too tall for my case side.

My Xig 1283 fits just fine in my Antec 900...the clearance looks closer than it really is...granted your CPU location may differ a little from my P35/Intel setup, I wouldn't think it'd be low enough to contact one of the "ears" for the side panel fan bracket mount.

My vote, in the Best-Bang-for-the-Budget, AC Freezer 7 Pro. Great cooler, I still have one cooling my G/F's OC'd C2D e6300 (@3.5GHz). Easy to install, overall it just works damn well...yes there are better, but in this products' price range (I purchased for around $26 over a year ago), you won't find better IMO (unless there's a really good sale...read on).

That's where my Xig comes in, I got it for $26.99 from a Newegg sale a couple months ago...been happy ever since. It does a better job in comparison to the AC, but in reality the difference I noticed wasn't more that 5C...which is still pretty damn good if you think about it. But in my results, that was the largest difference I noticed and that was under LOAD conditions, which should matter most anyways. This cooler, even at around $40 is still a good deal and cooler for the price range. I highly recommend it!

:toast:

MainframeTM
05-17-2008, 08:28 PM
take it you missed delivery? done that a few times myself, is an annoyance!

do me a favour, post us some thermal results / pictures once it arrives? that would be good, just before i purchase mine.

* 5 stars now :D *

250th post :D

Will do...i ordered it on friday & ups doesn't deliever on weekends :(

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 08:35 PM
My Xig 1283 fits just fine in my Antec 900...the clearance looks closer than it really is...granted your CPU location may differ a little from my P35/Intel setup, I wouldn't think it'd be low enough to contact one of the "ears" for the side panel fan bracket mount.

My vote, in the Best-Bang-for-the-Budget, AC Freezer 7 Pro. Great cooler, I still have one cooling my G/F's OC'd C2D e6300 (@3.5GHz). Easy to install, overall it just works damn well...yes there are better, but in this products' price range (I purchased for around $26 over a year ago), you won't find better IMO (unless there's a really good sale...read on).

That's where my Xig comes in, I got it for $26.99 from a Newegg sale a couple months ago...been happy ever since. It does a better job in comparison to the AC, but in reality the difference I noticed wasn't more that 5C...which is still pretty damn good if you think about it. But in my results, that was the largest difference I noticed and that was under LOAD conditions, which should matter most anyways. This cooler, even at around $40 is still a good deal and cooler for the price range. I highly recommend it!

:toast:

youve given me so much to consider haha . . . ima have to break out the ruler and check again. ill re post once i have measured :D

ShadowFold
05-17-2008, 08:37 PM
Dont get a AC Freezer, the mounting system on mine broke easily. Get a Xigmatek HDT series.

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 08:40 PM
Dont get a AC Freezer, the mounting system on mine broke easily. Get a Xigmatek HDT series.

im going to have to look them up, lots of people are referring to them. just worried about clearence issues :ohwell:

niko084
05-17-2008, 08:41 PM
im going to have to look them up, lots of people are referring to them. just worried about clearence issues :ohwell:

Are you sure the AC will fit, they are fairly tall also..

Kursah
05-17-2008, 08:43 PM
Here are some pics of my cooler installed from a month and a half ago or so, hell the tips of the heatpipes are just short of matching even with the end of the rear 120mm fan...you should be fine on clearance dude. Here ya go (all I have for now...sorry they're not recent...only real change is the vid card):

EDIT: Guess I should note that I do use it in vertical exhuast...actually dropped an extra 1-2C off load temps and 1C on the AC Freezer before I got the Xig...the Xig wouldn't clear my NB cooler for exhausting out of the rear so I never did a comparo there...I find there's no need to tho. It works quite well in this config!

kyle2020
05-17-2008, 08:53 PM
Here are some pics of my cooler installed from a month and a half ago or so, hell the tips of the heatpipes are just short of matching even with the end of the rear 120mm fan...you should be fine on clearance dude. Here ya go (all I have for now...sorry they're not recent...only real change is the vid card):

EDIT: Guess I should note that I do use it in vertical exhuast...actually dropped an extra 1-2C off load temps and 1C on the AC Freezer before I got the Xig...the Xig wouldn't clear my NB cooler for exhausting out of the rear so I never did a comparo there...I find there's no need to tho. It works quite well in this config!

by the looks of the first picture in particular, it seems in an antec 900 it will fit. ill have to compare prices now, just to finalize. thanks very much for the upload :toast:

echo75
05-17-2008, 08:54 PM
my Xigmatek fits fine and its just a midicase.