E8400 or Q6600?

dadi_oh · Apr 11, 2008

Well after some playing around with overclocking my ASUS P5K-E with both an E2160 and E2180 I am considering something more. I do have a watercooled setup so power shouldn't be an issue.

I found an E8400 on EBay for $200+$15 shipping and a Q6600 (SLACR Version GO Stepping) for $208+$12 shipping. So basically they are about the same price.

I do mostly gaming but also do video editing so the quadcore might come in handy. I also want to OC and I know the Q6600 can be tricky.

So what are your thoughts?

Darknova · Apr 11, 2008

E8400.

4Ghz should be easy, do that on a Q6600 without a TEC

Tatty_Two · Apr 11, 2008

Darknova said:
E8400.

4Ghz should be easy, do that on a Q6600 without a TEC

How about on a Thermalright Ultra extreme 120.......................this question seems to crop up a lot these days....my answer.....depends what you do with your PC mostly, if it's gaming or straightforward everyday tasks....the E8400 no question. If it's ripping CD's/DVD's, analogue to digital conversion etc etc then probably a Q6600.

JRMBelgium · Apr 11, 2008

I do a lot of video editing and I couldn't be more happy with my Q6600.
Sony Vegas has 100% CPU usage. My PC also converts to DIVX at 55-75fps.

PURE for gaming I would say for E8400, but if video editing is a hobby of yours, go for Q6600.

Becides, you have water cooling, you can get the Q6600 to 4Ghz.
My Q6600 is on 3.6Ghz on air and I play my games on 2048x1536...

dadi_oh · Apr 11, 2008

Tatty_One said:
How about on a Thermalright Ultra extreme 120.......................this question seems to crop up a lot these days....my answer.....depends what you do with your PC mostly, if it's gaming or straightforward everyday tasks....the E8400 no question. If it's ripping CD's/DVD's, analogue to digital conversion etc etc then probably a Q6600.

Yeah. I feel guilty for even bringing this up since it has been covered 4 billion times on the forums.

My thoughts...

Some people choose the E8400 since it is 45nm and therefore lower power. This allows them to get further in OC on air (even on stock cooler). The Q6600 is a lot hotter and therefore you may not get very far on air. Therefore the E8400 may be more economical for someone who wants to use stock cooler or maybe pick up something for $30.

In my situation I am on water so the power issue mostly disappears (I think). The question then becomes, for my purposes which would be a better choice? To be absolutley honest I should just be happy with my E2160 at 3.33GHz since it is probably more than I need 95% of the time. But like any tweaker I am always looking at what more I can get out of my setup. The idea of 4 processors at 3.4GHz vs. 2 processors at 4.0GHz just "sounds" nice

Even though I know there is very little out there that will use the 4 processors to their potential. But planning for future potential has always been a low percentage bet from my experience in the computing world.

In thinking it through I might be better of spending the $230 on a video card upgrade...

Someone stop me... I'm sick :laugh:

[I.R.A]_FBi · Apr 11, 2008

Q6600

JRMBelgium · Apr 11, 2008

dadi_oh said:
Yeah. I feel guilty for even bringing this up since it has been covered 4 billion times on the forums.

My thoughts...

Some people choose the E8400 since it is 45nm and therefore lower power. This allows them to get further in OC on air (even on stock cooler). The Q6600 is a lot hotter and therefore you may not get very far on air. Therefore the E8400 may be more economical for someone who wants to use stock cooler or maybe pick up something for $30.

In my situation I am on water so the power issue mostly disappears (I think). The question then becomes, for my purposes which would be a better choice? To be absolutley honest I should just be happy with my E2160 at 3.33GHz since it is probably more than I need 95% of the time. But like any tweaker I am always looking at what more I can get out of my setup. The idea of 4 processors at 3.4GHz vs. 2 processors at 4.0GHz just "sounds" nice Even though I know there is very little out there that will use the 4 processors to their potential. But planning for future potential has always been a low percentage bet from my experience in the computing world.

In thinking it through I might be better of spending the $230 on a video card upgrade...

Someone stop me... I'm sick

Well, like you already sad yourself. An E2160 at 3.33Ghz is really not that bad, not bad at all. Your 7900GT on the other hand...

Look, you've been gaming with the 7900GT for so long, I would say, keep on playing with it and save more money and buy the the first REAL decent next-gen single-GPU card that comes out.

newconroer · Apr 11, 2008

dadi_oh said:
But planning for future potential has always been a low percentage bet from my experience in the computing world.

Plan for the future, by curbing your obssession and waiting for Nehalem.

asb2106 · Apr 11, 2008

i say go with the q6600. For the price it is by far the best deal out there

You can get a solid 3.6 at pretty low voltage, I can run 3.6 @ 1.37 volts.

If you want to run higher it will take more voltage, and it does up exponentially then, but right now Im testing a 24/7 clock of 3.85 @ 1.58 volts. It stayed up all last night, and today Im gonna try to drop the voltages some.

But if you do more than gaming, anything like video editing, or converting, or even just for folding/seti, the q6600 is definitly worth it.

It any of those arent a concern, then get the e8400 and take the few extra Mhz.

dadi_oh · Apr 11, 2008

Jelle Mees said:
Well, like you already sad yourself. An E2160 at 3.33Ghz is really not that bad, not bad at all. Your 7900GT on the other hand...

Look, you've been gaming with the 7900GT for so long, I would say, keep on playing with it and save more money and buy the the first REAL decent next-gen single-GPU card that comes out.

Yeah. I had a pair of 7900GT's (OC to 7900GTX speeds) in SLI but then changed to a non-SLI motherboard. I just bought a 9600GT off someone on this board and am just waiting for it to arrive. Will probably watercool the 9600GT and see what I can do on OC.

I tend to be on the trailing edge of gaming as well. Just got COD4 last week. The 7900GT(X) is staying over 30fps at 1440X900 with a few settings dialed back but it would be nice to set everything to high. Quite impressed with the graphics even at my reduced settings.

asb2106 · Apr 11, 2008

dadi_oh said:
Yeah. I had a pair of 7900GT's (OC to 7900GTX speeds) in SLI but then changed to a non-SLI motherboard. I just bought a 9600GT off someone on this board and am just waiting for it to arrive. Will probably watercool the 9600GT and see what I can do on OC.

I tend to be on the trailing edge of gaming as well. Just got COD4 last week. The 7900GT(X) is staying over 30fps at 1440X900 with a few settings dialed back but it would be nice to set everything to high. Quite impressed with the graphics even at my reduced settings.

youll be very happy with the 9600gt.

I had one for a few weeks, and you can check some figures on it in my sig. With a quad core I was able to score 13k in 3dmark. I was able to clock to ~740 on the core.

this is my score in Vista, I didnt screen the XP run

dadi_oh · Apr 11, 2008

asb2106 said:
youll be very happy with the 9600gt.

I had one for a few weeks, and you can check some figures on it in my sig. With a quad core I was able to score 13k in 3dmark. I was able to clock to ~740 on the core.

this is my score in Vista, I didnt screen the XP run

Awesome. I am hoping to OC even higher on the 9600GT on water. The guy I am buying from had it to 810/1902/2200 on the stock cooler.

My 7900GT(X) is scoring about 6700 in 3dMark06 with my E2160 @ 3.3GHz. Doubling that would be awesome but more importantly I hope to play COD4 with all settings on high with my crappy 1440X900 display. Better display might also be a better spend than a processor right now... hmmmm...

asb2106 · Apr 11, 2008

dadi_oh said:
Awesome. I am hoping to OC even higher on the 9600GT on water. The guy I am buying from had it to 810/1902/2200 on the stock cooler.

My 7900GT(X) is scoring about 6700 in 3dMark06 with my E2160 @ 3.3GHz. Doubling that would be awesome but more importantly I hope to play COD4 with all settings on high with my crappy 1440X900 display. Better display might also be a better spend than a processor right now... hmmmm...

that was one hell of a card! And with water youll be able to keep those temps under control! With a quad running 3.6 or higher in XP you could probably score 14k

System Name	Sonny Boy
Processor	i5 11600K 4.9GHz @ 1.35 Vcore
Motherboard	AORUS Z590 Elite AX
Cooling	Deepcool Gammix 240mm AIO
Memory	4 X 8GB Teamgroup DDR4 3200MHz
Video Card(s)	ASUS RTX 3060 Ti GDDR6X
Storage	Adata Legend 1TB
Display(s)	Philips 27" 4K
Power Supply	Corsair 750W
Mouse	Razer Basilisk
Keyboard	Razer Huntsman V2
Software	Windows 11 Pro

Processor	AMD FX 8320 @ 4GHz
Motherboard	Gigabyte GA-990FXA-UD5 rev1
Cooling	Corsair H70
Memory	4 x 4GB DDR3 Ripjawz 1600Mhz
Video Card(s)	Sapphire Vapor-X AMD R9 280X
Storage	1 x 500GB Samsung Evo 850, 1 x 500GB Vrap Data Drive, 3 x 2TB Seagate, 1 x 1TB Samsung F1
Display(s)	3 x DGM IPS-2402WDH
Case	Coolermaster HAF X
Audio Device(s)	Onboard
Power Supply	Coolermaster 1000W Silent Pro M
Mouse	Logitech G502
Keyboard	Logitech G510
Software	Windows 10 Pro x64

Processor	Rocket Lake Core i5 11600K @ 5 Ghz with PL tweaks
Motherboard	MSI MAG Z490 TOMAHAWK
Cooling	Thermalright Peerless Assassin 120SE + 4 Phanteks 140mm case fans
Memory	32GB (4 x 8GB SR) Patriot Viper Steel 4133Mhz DDR4 @ 3600Mhz CL14@1.45v Gear 1
Video Card(s)	Asus Dual RTX 4070 OC
Storage	WD Blue SN550 1TB M.2 NVME//Crucial MX500 500GB SSD (OS)
Display(s)	AOC Q2781PQ 27 inch Ultra Slim 2560 x 1440 IPS
Case	Phanteks Enthoo Pro M Windowed - Gunmetal
Audio Device(s)	Onboard Realtek ALC1200/SPDIF to Sony AVR @ 5.1
Power Supply	Seasonic CORE GM650w Gold Semi modular
Mouse	Coolermaster Storm Octane wired
Keyboard	Element Gaming Carbon Mk2 Tournament Mech
Software	Win 10 Home x64

System Name	Meshify C Ryzen 2019
Processor	AMD Ryzen 3900X
Motherboard	X470 AORUS ULTRA GAMING
Cooling	AMD Wraith Prism LED Cooler
Memory	32GB DDR4 ( F4-3200C16D-32GTZKW, 16-16-16-36 @ 3200Mhz )
Video Card(s)	AMD Radeon RX6800 ( 2400Mhz/2150Mhz )
Storage	Samsung Evo 960
Display(s)	Pixio PX275h
Case	Fractal Design Meshify C – Dark TG
Audio Device(s)	Sennheiser GSP 300 ( Headset )
Power Supply	Seasonic FOCUS Plus Series 650W
Mouse	Logitech G502
Keyboard	Logitech G 15
Software	Windows 10 Pro 64bit

System Name	Sonny Boy
Processor	i5 11600K 4.9GHz @ 1.35 Vcore
Motherboard	AORUS Z590 Elite AX
Cooling	Deepcool Gammix 240mm AIO
Memory	4 X 8GB Teamgroup DDR4 3200MHz
Video Card(s)	ASUS RTX 3060 Ti GDDR6X
Storage	Adata Legend 1TB
Display(s)	Philips 27" 4K
Power Supply	Corsair 750W
Mouse	Razer Basilisk
Keyboard	Razer Huntsman V2
Software	Windows 11 Pro

Processor	C2Q6600 @ 1.6 GHz
Motherboard	Anus PQ5
Cooling	ACFPro
Memory	GEiL2 x 1 GB PC2 6400
Video Card(s)	MSi 4830 (RIP)
Storage	Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 320 GB Perpendicular Recording
Display(s)	Dell 17'
Case	El Cheepo
Audio Device(s)	7.1 Onboard
Power Supply	Corsair TX750
Software	MCE2K5

System Name	Widow
Processor	Ryzen 7600x
Motherboard	AsRock B650 HDVM.2
Cooling	CPU : Corsair Hydro XC7 }{ GPU: EK FC 1080 via Magicool 360 III PRO > Photon 170 (D5)
Memory	32GB Gskill Flare X5
Video Card(s)	GTX 1080 TI
Storage	Samsung 9series NVM 2TB and Rust
Display(s)	Predator X34P/Tempest X270OC @ 120hz / LG W3000h
Case	Fractal Define S [Antec Skeleton hanging in hall of fame]
Audio Device(s)	Asus Xonar Xense with AKG K612 cans on Monacor SA-100
Power Supply	Seasonic X-850
Mouse	Razer Naga 2014
Software	Windows 11 Pro
Benchmark Scores	FFXIV ARR Benchmark 12,883 on i7 2600k 15,098 on AM5 7600x

System Name	File Server
Processor	2600k
Motherboard	idk
Cooling	H110
Memory	20gb of something
Video Card(s)	onboard!
Storage	2x120 SSD, (5x8tb)+(3x4tb) = 35 TB Z1 pool
Display(s)	couple 4k 32s
Case	cooler master something i think
Audio Device(s)	does anyone bother with anything but onboard?
Power Supply	Whatever OCZ PC Powercooling became. 1200 modular setup
Mouse	MX Master 2x
Keyboard	G710
Software	FreeNAS

E8400 or Q6600?

Gone Fishing